Productivity
Spoken lists are terrible lists. Here's the fix
Say five things and you get a run-on sentence with "and" in it four times. Getting actual bullets takes either a small speaking habit or a rewrite step.
Last updated
Why it comes out wrong
Speech is linear and has no concept of a line break. When you say a list, what you produce is a sentence — and a speech model faithfully writes down a sentence.
What you said
so for Thursday we need the pricing slide updated and someone to chase legal about the contract and I should probably confirm the room and we still haven't sent the pre-read
What you wanted
- Update the pricing slide
- Chase legal about the contract
- Confirm the room
- Send the pre-read
The content is identical. The second version is scannable and the first is not, and scannable is the entire reason you wanted a list.
Method one: say the structure
Start the list in the app — the hyphen, the bullet button, whatever it uses — then dictate each item and say "new line" between them.
- Start the list by hand Type a hyphen and a space, or use the app's list control. Do not try to dictate list formatting.
- Dictate the first item Short. A bullet is not a sentence.
- Say "new line" In most apps this creates the next bullet automatically, because the app is continuing the list.
- Carry on One breath per item is roughly the right rhythm.
- Press Enter twice to finish Exits the list in most editors.
Pros: exact control, works everywhere, no model involved. Cons: you have to know the items before you start speaking, which defeats the purpose when you are thinking out loud.
Method two: dictate normally, rewrite into bullets
Say the list as an ordinary sentence, the way it came out of your head, and let a rewrite step lay it out. This is the method to use when you are working out what the list is while saying it.
It handles the things a spoken list always has: the "and" between every item, the one you remembered at the end and appended with "oh and also", and the item you started twice.
Transforms in VV Bullets as a style on the recording overlay. Runs on your Mac, so it works offline.How to speak a list so it converts well
- Signal that a list is coming. "There are four things." Both methods handle it better, and so does a human reader.
- Keep items short. A bullet that runs to three clauses is a paragraph wearing a dot.
- Use parallel grammar. All verbs, or all nouns. "Update the slide, chase legal, confirm the room" converts cleanly; mixing forms does not.
- Pause between items. Half a second. It helps both the model and the read-back.
- Do not number them aloud unless the order matters. "First, second, third" becomes literal text and then you have both a number and a bullet.
Where it still goes wrong
| Symptom | Cause | Fix |
|---|---|---|
| Everything in one bullet | No structure said, no rewrite applied | Say "new line", or use a rewrite step |
| An item missing | The rewrite dropped a short one | Count them. Always |
| Numbers and bullets together | You said "first, second" inside a bulleted list | Pick one — the list formatting or the spoken numbering |
| Nested levels wrong | Speech has no way to express indentation | Do nesting by hand. It is not a dictation task |
| The list starts a slash command | In Notion, a leading slash opens the menu | Start with a word, or type the structure first |
Questions
Can I just say "bullet point"?
In some apps and some tools, yes. It is inconsistent enough across applications that it is not worth relying on. "New line" inside a list the app has already started is far more reliable, because the app is doing the formatting.
Does automatic bullet formatting lose items?
Occasionally, usually the last one or a very short one. Count what you said against what you got. VV lays lists out deterministically rather than trusting the model to, which reduces this, and it is still worth counting.
Can I dictate nested lists?
Not reliably. Speech has no natural way to express indentation. Dictate the items flat and indent by hand — it is a keyboard task.
Does this work in Notion, Word and Google Docs?
Yes, in all of them. Start the list using the app's own mechanism, then dictate the items. The dictation is only supplying the words.